Reviewed by Colin Jacobson (November 24, 2021)
According to Wikipedia, Werewolves Within was a 2016 “virtual reality” game. I never heard of it, but none of this impacted my decision to watch a 2021 live-action film adaptation that uses the same title.
Set in the frigid setting of Beaverfield, a new forest ranger named Finn Wheeler (Sam Richardson) arrives in town. There he makes friends with mail carrier Cecily Moore (Milana Vayntrub) and he gets to know the eccentric locals.
Eventually a massive snowstorm causes a power outage and leaves most of the Beaverfieldians stuck in the town’s inn. Finn and Cecily attempt to maintain calm as a strange creature stalks the townsfolk.
Gee, you don’t suppose this will turn out to be a werewolf, do you? No spoilers, as I believe the movie’s title gives away that plot point.
Actually, even though my synopsis implies Within implies that no terror occurs until a decent chunk of film passes, the film opens with some violent action. Granted, this acts as a teaser and doesn’t reveal the nature of the culprit, but it does set up the eventual tone.
Of course, we find a couple of clues that Within will lean toward the comedic side of the horror genre. For one, my mention of “eccentric locals” offers a hint, as characters of that sort usually go for attempted laughs.
In addition, the presence of Richardson as our lead brings another indication of the movie’s tone. Probably best known as Richard Splett on Veep, he works mainly in comedy, so the use of Richardson as our main role gives us a strong hint of the movie’s direction.
Vayntrub and other castmembers also come with comedic backgrounds, so expect a lot of comedic elements here. Even when the movie attempts some horror, the lighter side dominates.
And that works fine, as Within provides a reasonably amusing affair – albeit one that displays a lot of non-comedic influences. In addition to the usual werewolf tales, we get hints of Agatha Christie, Jaws and John Carpenter’s Thing. These references can seem a bit ham-fisted, but don’t become a problem.
The comedy never seems especially creative, as the wacky characters can feel contrived and cliché. Still, the actors bring gusto to the parts and make them generally amusing.
I like that Within leaves open some mystery about whether or not a werewolf actually exists, too. The movie can lack coherence at times and feel like it tries too hard to throw the viewer off the scent, but at least it gives us some narrative ambition.
Nothing here elevates the project to greatness, but I don’t regard that as a sin. Werewolves Within delivers a brisk and mostly entertaining mix of horror and comedy.