Moviegoers in 2005 could be excused if they felt a feeling of déjà vu. With both a Star Wars flick and a Steven Spielberg movie about aliens coming to Earth, it felt like 1977 all over again.

Few will say that Revenge of the Sith and War of the Worlds live up to Star Wars and Close Encounters of the Third Kind. However, both movies are good, and the timing led to a fun sense of nostalgia. At least 2005 beat 2002. That year also had a new Star Wars flick and a Spielberg sci-fi offering, both of which were entertaining but rather erratic.

One could say the same about War and Sith, I suppose, but I think both films suffer from fewer flaws than their 2002 counterparts. In Spielberg’s War, we meet Ray Ferrier (Tom Cruise), a divorced dockworker who doesn’t often see his kids. Teenage Robbie (Justin Chatwin) and 10-year-old Rachel (Dakota Fanning) don’t maintain a close relationship with their dad, mostly because he’s a selfish dude who doesn’t know much about raising children.

After some awkward moments among the family, different matters take priority when an electrical storm zaps the area. This turns out to be an alien invasion, as the residents realize when an enormous three-legged craft comes out the street and starts to zap everyone it can. From there the movie follows Ray’s attempts to keep himself and his kids alive.

Funny – after 9/11, weren’t we all told that no one would make this kind of movie anymore? War shows many hallmarks of being a product of the post-9/11 world, partially through its occasional allusions to that event. Shots of Ray covered in ashes as well as posters that list missing people overtly recall that event, and other elements hearken back to it as well. Spielberg doesn’t pour on the connections, but he brings enough of them to give the film a dark evocation of that period.

I think 9/11 also impacted War due to its inherent darkness. When I reviewed Minority Report, I mentioned that Spielberg lacked the coldness to make the movie as rough and gritty as it deserved. He leavened the tale with self-conscious comic moments that lessened its impact.

Spielberg doesn’t make the same mistake here. Sure, the occasional funny moment occurs, but the vast majority take place before the attack. In contrast with his usual attitude, here Spielberg seems to revel in the aggressiveness and tension. He doesn’t deflate these segments; instead, he makes them even more intense.

Most filmmakers get softer as they age, but Spielberg appears to be on the opposite path. Over the last few years, he’s made movies that are notably darker than anything he did in his first decade or so. There’s no way the Spielberg of the late Seventies or early Eighties could have made such a dark film.

Of course, you shouldn’t take that as a criticism of those movies, as they remain his best. With the exception of 1979’s 1941, Spielberg was virtually flawless from 1975 to 1982. However, a War made by Spielberg in 1980 would have been lighter than the one he made in 2005, as I don’t think he could have created anything nearly as disturbing.

Remarkably, Spielberg avoids a sense of reassurance for the audience. Usually we get the impression that no matter how bad things get, everything will be fine in the end. That doesn’t occur during War. Instead, the movie just goes from bad to worse, and it’s hard to envision a satisfying resolution.

I don’t think it ruins anything to indicate that War does end on a positive note; heck, it concludes the same way as a book that’s been around for more than 100 years, so the finale is well-known. Actually, the ending comes as a bit of a letdown in the way Spielberg executes it. I won’t go into specifics, but he leaves open some odd plot holes and doesn’t give the flick a tremendously satisfying finish.

Otherwise, Spielberg fires on all cylinders throughout War. Truly, I never thought he could create a movie with quite this much darkness and tension. I admired George Lucas because he didn’t wimp out when it came to the harsher aspects of Sith, and I have to give the same praise to Spielberg. War gets classified as sci-fi action, but in many ways it falls into the horror genre. This is a cold, scary flick.

Some worried that Cruise’s bizarre behavior would harpoon the movie’s prospects. He created such a strange buzz about himself that it might turn off moviegoers. I was a little concerned about this myself, in that I wasn’t sure I’d be able to turn off my thoughts about Annoying Tom Cruise and accept Actor Tom Cruise.

The latter came to the forefront in War via a surprisingly strong performance. I didn’t think Cruise made much sense as the delinquent dad, but he pulls off the role with gusto. He makes Ray’s transition totally believable and even seems convincing as a blue collar Jersey dude. Although Cruise had the potential to harm the movie, he greatly benefits it.

As one who often criticizes computer graphics, I thought I get turned off by the rampant CG of War. That’s not the case. With only minor exceptions, the effects are splendid. They blend very well with the action and give the movie the awe-inspiring grandeur it deserves. For once I was able to forget that I was watching CG and simply invest myself in the story.

Is there anything I didn’t like about War? I suppose there are too many of the usual movie coincidences, and the characters of the kids don’t get explored very well. But that’s about it, as otherwise I think the movie succeeds. Spielberg’s best movie in years, War of the Worlds marks a true return to form for the director. I hope we get more of this sort of exciting “popcorn flick” from him in the future.

War of the Worlds appears in an aspect ratio of approximately 1.85:1 on this Blu-ray Disc. Though usually attractive, I found more problems than I expected.

Not that this was ever going to be a movie that looked great. As shot, it was meant to be grainy and less than razor-sharp. This meant that though overall clarity was good, some elements appeared a bit soft. That came from the cinematography, though, and didn’t appear to be an artifact of the transfer.

On the other hand, the image suffered from a surprising number of source flaws, especially during its opening third or so. I saw sporadic instances of specks and spots in the film’s early portions. These decreased as the movie progressed, but I was surprised to see any defects in a big-budget flick from 2005; outside of all the intentional grain, this should’ve been a clean image.

Much of the time, War featured a desaturated image. As with a few other recent Spielberg movies, it preferred a cold, blown-out look, though some colors still crept through at times. For instance, some of Rachel’s clothes and accessories showed decent definition, and the red vines that appeared toward the end looked full and menacingly rich. The disc appeared to present the colors as intended, and they worked fine in that realm.

Despite the washed-out presentation, black levels looked dark and dense, while shadow detail was appropriately opaque but not too thick. Low-light sequences were clear and distinct. In the end, a fair amount of the transfer looked good – or at least true to its source – but the source flaws made me lower my grade to a “B-“.

On the other hand, I found no problems at all during the top-notch DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack. The soundfield presented an active and lively piece that constantly engaged the five main speakers. The film showed distinctive imagery throughout the movie that placed different auditory elements accurately within the spectrum and meshed them together nicely. Music provided strong stereo imaging, and effects popped up from the appropriate locations. Quieter scenes displayed natural ambience, while the many action set pieces involved engrossing and vibrant imaging. It became tough to pick a favorite sequence, but the opening attack probably remained my favorite due to the sheer impact of its chaos.

Audio quality also seemed positive. Speech consistently appeared natural and crisp, and I noticed no issues related to edginess or intelligibility. Music sounded bright and dynamic as the disc neatly replicated the score. Effects packed a nice wallop when necessary, as these elements seemed clean and distinct at all times. Bass response came across as deep and tight, and the low-end added a good layer of depth and oomph to the package. This was a soundtrack to challenge your subwoofer, as it really administered a heavy punch. I thought this was a consistently amazing soundtrack that earned a rare “A+”.

The Blu-ray replicates almost all of the extras from the two-disc DVD. A series of 12 featurettes gives us all the information about War.

These start with Revisiting the Invasion. The seven-minute and 35-second piece establishes the format all its siblings will use, as we find a mix of movie clips, behind the scenes footage, and interviews. Here we get comments from Spielberg, actor Tom Cruise, screenwriter David Koepp, and executive producer Paula Wagner. They discuss Spielberg’s childhood influences in regard to similar films, the decision to partner with Cruise again, what they did and didn’t want to include in this version, and some story points. A few decent notes pop up here, but the program seems too general to present much useful material.

In the six-minute and 36-second The HG Wells Legacy, we hear from Spielberg, grandson Martin wells, and great-grandson Simon Wells. We get a few notes about HG’s life and career as well as the enduring appeal of War. As with “Invasion”, a smattering of good bits appear, but there’s not much depth.

The eight-minute Steven Spielberg and the Original War of the Worlds includes comments from Spielberg, costume designer Joanna Johnston, senior visual effects supervisor Dennis Muren, and actors Gene Barry and Ann Robinson. We learn a little about the 1953 War as well as its influence on the creators of this flick. If you want to know about the 1953 flick, it makes more sense to check out its DVD. The information here isn’t more than a teaser, and the notes about how the film affected Spielberg and the others don’t tell us much.

Characters: The Family Unit includes information from Spielberg, Cruise, Koepp, Johnston, and actors Dakota Fanning, Justin Chatwin and Miranda Otto. In this 13-minute and 15-second piece, they discuss Cruise’s role and look, casting and the nuances of the various roles. We find decent notes about the characters; I especially like Koepp’s remarks about how he wanted to update Cruise’s parts from his earliest films. The best segments come from the on-the-set footage, though. Cruise makes a funny reference to another flick of his, and it’s also amusing to see Spielberg refer to Fanning by her character’s name.

As we go to Pre-Visualization, we find a seven-minute and 43-second look at that area. It features notes from Spielberg, pre-visualization supervisor Dan Gregoire, and producer Colin Wilson. They talk about the use of pre-vis on War and how it aided the production. I like the glimpses of the pre-vis shots created for the film, and we get a nice impression of how Spielberg used them.

The next four featurettes all come under the banner of Production Diaries. These include “East Coast – Beginning” (22 minutes, 30 seconds), “East Coast – Exile” (19:39), “West Coast – Destruction” (27:29) and “West Coast – War” (22:20). These feature information from Spielberg, Cruise, Wilson, Muren, Johnston, Wagner, Koepp, Fanning, Chatwin, director of photography Janusz Kaminski, producer Kathleen Kennedy, visual effects supervisor Pablo Helman, production designer Rick Carter, concept designer Doug Chiang, property master Doug Harlocker, stunt coordinator Vic Armstrong, special effects coordinator Daniel Sudick, digital production supervisor Curt Miyashiro, military technical advisor Major Joseph Todd Breasseale, model/miniature supervisor Steve Gawley, actor Tim Robbins, set decorator Ann Kuljian, compositing supervisor Marshall Krasser.

The diaries start on October 11, 2004 and progress through March 7, 2005. We learn about the rushed production schedule, location scouts, visual design, principal photography and some specifics of filming including stunts, props and practical effects, computer-generated and other visual elements, extras, clothes, and using real soldiers. When we get to the west coast, we learn about sets, scheduling, the Ogilvy character and that sequence, more stunts and visual effects, design of alien elements, battle scenes, and the end of principal photography.

With a program of this sort, I mostly expect lots of good footage from the set, and the “Diaries” offer that in spades. We get a great deal of fine “fly on the wall” material, and the comments embellish those images well. All of this adds up to an informative look at the filming that covers many different areas.

After this we get the 14-minute and seven-second Designing the Enemy; Tripods and Aliens. It includes remarks from Spielberg, Koepp, Chiang, Muren, Kennedy, Cruise, Simon Wells, ILM creature designer Ryan Church, associate animation supervisor Jenn Emberly, digital model supervisor Michael Koperwas, and animation supervisor Randal M. Dutra. As you’d expect, this show covers decisions made in regard to the alien elements. We find out why they chose to depict the tripods and the aliens as they did. The program goes over all these areas quite well and touches on the topics with reasonable detail and depth. Heck, we even get some background on the aliens, and Spielberg lets us know that they’re not Martians!

Scoring War of the Worlds lasts 11 minutes and 57 seconds and offers statements from Spielberg, Wilson, and composer John Williams. We learn how the rushed schedule affected Williams’ work and also what he wanted to convey with his music. This turns into another informative piece.

For the final featurette, we get the three-minute and 15-second We Are Not Alone. A valedictory program, it features comments from Spielberg, Kennedy, and Cruise. They talk about what a great experience the film was and offer some minor connections to Spielberg’s other works and his life. The clip wraps things up in an innocuous but none too interesting way.

The Blu-ray loses “Production Notes” from the DVD but adds the film’s teaser trailer. Finally, we find four Galleries. These include “Sketches by Costume Designer Joanna Johnston” (nine frames), “Production Stills” (17), “Behind the Scenes” (20) and “Production Sketches” (30). The various artwork is pretty good, but the photos are a waste of time.

A science-fiction film by Steven Spielberg has to fill some big shoes. A thoroughly exciting and enjoyable action/horror flick, War of the Worlds lives up to expectations. I wouldn’t classify it on the level of Spielberg’s absolute best work, but it’s definitely one of the strongest movies he’s made in years. The Blu-ray offers top-notch audio and some interesting extras, but picture quality disappoints. If you don’t already own War, I’d recommend the Blu-ray, but the visual weaknesses make it hard to endorse as a replacement for the old DVD.

To rate this film visit the Limited Edition review of WAR OF THE WORLDS (2005)