Sample line from my review of 2000’s Scary Movie: “It seemed absolutely interminable as one tacky, unfunny gag followed another until I hoped a masked maniac would slaughter me.” Sample line from my review of 2001’s Scary Movie 2: “It felt like a pretty lousy piece as a whole. Its positives were minor, while its negatives seemed large.”

With those experiences as a backdrop, did I anticipate that I’d actually enjoy 2003’s Scary Movie 3? Not really, but hope springs eternal.

Scary 3 launches with a prologue in which silicone-enhanced babes Becca (Pamela Anderson) and Kate (Jenny McCarthy) watch TV. This introduces the concept of a videotape that kills; everyone who watches it dies within seven days, and Kate buys it at the start of the film.

We never see Becca again, as the movie quickly shifts to rural Virginia and the farm of estranged minister Tom Logan (Charlie Sheen). Aliens leave a message in his cornfield that reads “Attack Here”. Tom’s younger brother George (Simon Rex) wants to be a rapper so he heads to Washington DC to enter a rap battle.

When he gets there, he runs into Cindy Campbell (Anna Faris). One of two characters to carry over from all prior Scary flicks, she now works as a news anchor for a DC station, and she wants to follow the crop circles story. She met George when she investigated it on the farm, and the two show some romantic glimmerings.

Cindy cares for her nephew Cody (Drew Mikuska). He has pre-cognitive visions and seems generally creepy. Cindy’s friend Brenda (Regina Hall) – the other carryover from prior movies - runs a day care center and also watches the deadly videotape. Not exactly heavy on plot, the rest of Scary follows the threads connected to the videotape, the aliens and the crop circles, as all of them sort of tie together in the end.

While still a spoof, Scary Movie 3 somewhat differs from its two predecessors because it boasts a different team behind it. Instead of the Wayans brothers, here we find David Zucker at the helm. Zucker brings with him much experience in comedy, with hits like Airplane and Ruthless People on his résumé.

Does Zucker’s presence alter the equation? Yes, to a moderate degree. The first two focused heavily on rampantly offensive humor, as they targeted many different groups in a nasty way. They also poured on crude sexual bits and other elements of unpleasantness.

Both of the first two flick boasted “R” ratings, while Scary Movie 3 goes for a slightly more gentle “PG-13”. This means pubic hair gags get the boot, while ones about looking up skirts appear. I don’t know if this came as an edict from the suits at Dimension to allow more young viewers to see it or if it’s due to a difference between the comedic philosophies of Zucker and the Wayans, but this flick does seem noticeably less offensive than its predecessors.

Within reason, at least. Instead of crude sex-related gags, Scary Movie 3 accentuates violent humor. Any body part that can be hit will be hit. This elevates to ridiculous levels and leaves me with the feeling that the filmmakers resorted to slapstick when they couldn’t think of anything better to do. Given that a surprising amount of the violence falls upon the Cody character, the decision seems even more problematic; I’m not excessively politically correct, but I don’t know if I care for a flick that inflicts so much violence – cartoon or not – on a kid.

When the movie doesn’t whack around people, it concentrates on body parts or bodily functions. This means lots of vomit/urine/defecation gags as well as many connected to breasts/penises/testicles. The difference between Scary Movie 3 and the prior flicks comes from how it examines these areas. The first two did so in a graphic manner, whereas this one seems lighter. It’s the difference between referring to breasts as “tits” or “boobs”; the first is the harsher phrase and fits the first two flicks, while the second is more appropriate for the third movie.

Not that much of this stuff adds up to actual laughs. All of the movies in the series take the “throw it at the wall” approach to humor. They toss out any gag they can conjure and hope some of them cling. Actually, during the early parts of the movie, a few of them seem almost sort of amusing. The pairing of Playboy icons Anderson and McCarthy provides some minor chuckles, even though I wonder when Pam totally lost any resemblance to an actual human being. I still think Regina Hall’s Brenda is the best thing about the series, as she parodies the sassy black woman character nicely.

Unfortunately, the meandering story causes problems. Scary 3 tosses in random elements from other movies, but its main focus remains a mix of The Ring and Signs. Sometimes it takes rather literally from its sources, such as a parody of the Signs scene in which the wife of Mel Gibson’s character dies. This seems like lazy comedy and it doesn’t work, especially in regard to that sequence; the filmmakers copy the segment so closely that the combination of tragedy and comedy don’t integrate.

Mostly the plots just feel like they meander and don’t really coalesce. Granted, no one sees this kind of movie for a tight storyline, but Scary 3 could have become less rambling than this. The ending ties things together but not in a way that we really buy.

One other problem stems from the fact the filmmakers never quite know how to quit. They extend many of the gags well beyond the point of effectiveness. Even ones that have some potential often continue past their expiration date, and that renders them less enjoyable.

Ultimately, Scary Movie 3 tosses out enough manic humor that it inspires an occasional chuckle. Unfortunately, it quickly hits a wall and just repeats the same form of gags over and over with little inspiration or creativity. It’s another tedious exercise in cheap humor.

Note that this disc offers a version of the movie titled Scary Movie 3.5. It's an unrated cut that lasts all of one minute longer than the 84-minute theatrical edition. From what I can tell, the longer Scary just adds a risqué line here and a naughty comment there. It reincorporates material excised for ratings purposes, so no major additions occur. It's the same unfunny stuff.

Scary Movie 3.5 appears in an aspect ratio of approximately 1.85:1 on this Blu-ray Disc. The image had its strengths but also could be pretty mediocre.

Sharpness was decent to good. Some shots came across as a little loose, but much of the movie seemed acceptably distinctive and accurate. I saw no problems with jagged edges or shimmering, but some light edge enhancement cropped up at times. Occasional specks popped up along the way; these weren’t heavy, but they appeared more frequently than I’d like.

The colors worked fine. They lacked any runniness or bleeding and seemed positive across the board. The various hues were tight and bold. Black levels appeared nicely dense and deep, while low-light shots offered good clarity and definition. Despite the occasional mushiness, this was a generally positive presentation.

While much of Scary Movie 3.5’s DTS-HD MA 5.1 mix sounded great, it lacked the scope to earn a high grade. The soundfield remained quite limited through most of the movie. Elements remained mostly anchored in the front speakers. Music managed to get decent reinforcement from the rear, and an occasional effect cropped up back there, but not more than on a few minor occasions.

Otherwise, however, the fronts heavily dominated. They offered good localization and movement, though. The forward speakers presented a fairly natural soundfield, but it still wasn’t terribly involving.

At least audio quality seemed terrific. Dialogue always sounded natural and distinctive, and I noticed no issues connected to edginess or intelligibility. Effects sounded accurate and life-like. Music fared quite well. From the score to the rap or pop/rock songs, these all seemed vivid and lively, with clear highs and nice bass. Across the board, low-end response was firm and rich. Overall, Scary lost points due to its lack of ambition, but it sounded good enough to earn a “B”.

How did the picture and sound quality of the Blu-ray compare with those of the original Scary Movie 3.5 DVD? Audio was a bit bolder and more dynamic, while visuals showed great definition. Though this wasn’t a great image, it worked better than the DVD.

Most of the Scary Movie 3.5 DVD’s extras repeat here. We open with an audio commentary from director David Zucker, producer Robert K. Weiss, and writers Craig Mazin and Pat Proft. All four men sit together for this running, screen-specific chat. Although it presents a rollicking and wisecracking tone, it doesn’t offer a great deal of information.

The majority of the notes deal with alterations made to originally scripted or shot footage. We hear a lot about deleted scenes as well as changes made for ratings concerns. Though the participants gleefully tell us when things didn’t work, the commentary still suffers from an excess of praise for the flick; they happily relate how terrific they feel much of it is. The guys remain glib and impudent enough to make the track generally entertaining, but it doesn’t provide a great look at the movie.

Note that this release includes a different commentary than the one found on the original theatrical cut DVD. If you compare the remarks above to what I said about that disc's commentary, you'll notice they're identical. Even though this is a different discussion, it works in an extremely similar way. It has the same participants as well as the same mix of good and bad elements. I guess it makes sense that a second chat with the same guys would turn out the same way, but it will come as a disappointment for those who hope to hear fresh information.

Up next we find 14 deleted and extended scenes and a separate Alternate Ending. These fill a total of 35 minutes and 51 seconds. The bulk of the material comes from the alternate ending; this takes a whopping 15 minutes, 28 seconds alone! Unsurprisingly, it offers the biggest component here, as it gets into elements related to The Hulk and the Matrix sequels. The various clips seem to have mostly been omitted for time, as they come across as neither better nor worse than the material in the final flick.

All of these scenes can be viewed with or without commentary from the four guys who chatted during the main film. They present the same flippant tone, but it works less well here. Much of the time they tell us little about the scenes or why they cut them. Instead, they mostly just complain about the clips and tell us they’re terrible. Granted, we already learn a lot of this during the main commentary, but this nonetheless comes across as a pretty pointless track since it doesn’t have much information in it.

Note that this package includes six deleted scenes that don’t appear on the original theatrical disc. These add nine minutes and 6 seconds of footage. Apparently we lose one short clip from the prior release, since it presented 10 cut sequences. Unfortunately, I don’t remember that set well enough to figure out what got left out here, but I’d not be surprised to learn that it was something reincorporated in the extended version of the film.

None of the new pieces seem terribly interesting, though one with some hot girls in a baby oil spill is… stimulating. The commentary is slightly more informative for the new clips, though I think it was recorded at the same time as the rest of the package. At least the guys tell us a few tidbits about why those pieces were cut.

Making Scary Movie 3 runs 23 minutes and 21 seconds. We find the normal collection of movie snippets, shots from the set, and interviews. We hear from producer Bob Weiss, director David Zucker, actors Jenny McCarthy, Anna Faris, Kevin Hart, Eddie Griffin, Simon Rex, Queen Latifah, Jianna Ballard, Fat Joe, DL Hughley, Ja Rule, Master P, Redman, Method Man, Macy Gray, Charlie Sheen, and Leslie Nielsen. They chat about production values, constant changes to the script, the cast and their work on the film, Zucker’s style, and the film’s humor. The cast subjects heavily dominate the program, as we hear some minor notes about their development but mostly get comments about how wonderful they all were. Some of the material from the set seems intriguing, but the show mainly seems fluffy and insubstantial.

Next we get another program called Making Scary Movie 3... FOR REAL. It lasts four minutes, 53 seconds as it goes over some general things in a nutty way. It uses the same format as the prior program and includes comments from Zucker plus actors Regina Hall, Anna Faris, Bob Weiss, Darrell Hammond, Simon Rex, DL Hughley, Camryn Manheim, and Anthony Anderson. Mostly we see nuttiness from the set and comedic asides from the participants. It doesn’t tell us much, but some of the shots from the set offer a bit of fun.

In the Outtakes and Bloopers area we see three minutes, 59 seconds of footage. Mostly this offered the usual collection of goofs and wackiness. However, some minor deleted scenes pop up as well, which makes the set more interesting than normal.

We take a look Behind the Scenes of the Alternate Ending in the next segment. This four-minute and eight-second piece examines “Hulk vs. Aliens”. It uses the standard format and we get remarks from Zucker, Weiss, visual effects supervisor Stuart Robertson, makeup effects creators Tom Woodruff Jr. and Alec Gillis. They discuss the look of the aliens as well as the costumes, visual effects, and execution of the elements. It’s a pretty tight little examination of the subjects.

The disc opens with ads for Scary Movie, Scary Movie 2, and the Scream trilogy. These reappear in the disc’s trailers area, but no ads for Scary 3 show up here.

Despite the arrival of a new creative team behind Scary Movie 3, don’t expect superior results. The movie tames things a little but remains generally crude and unfunny. The unrated Scary Movie 3 tosses out a few more explicit bits cut from the theatrical edition, but it doesn't add laughs. The Blu-ray provides erratic but generally good picture along with pretty positive audio and a nice set of supplements. This is a decent release for a fairly lame flick.

To rate this film, visit the original review of SCARY MOVIE 3