Reviewed by Colin Jacobson (June 2, 2022)
When we last saw Joaquin Phoenix, he starred as the title character in 2019’s Joker and took home an Oscar for his work. After that big studio effort, Phoenix returns with 2021’s indie flick C’mon C’mon.
Radio journalist Johnny (Phoenix) leads a nomadic life, as his job places him in spots all around the US. Emotionally immature, Johnny lacks much contact with family, mainly because of the aftereffects related to his mother’s death.
Johnny reconnects with his semi-estranged sister Viv (Gaby Hoffman) as she deals with issues connected to her ex-husband Paul (Scoot McNairy). This leads Johnny to visit her in LA, where he encounters his nine-year-old nephew Jesse (Woody Norman).
Viv needs to go to Northern California to work through problems with Paul, and that means she could use a babysitter. Due to his job, though, Johnny can’t stay in LA with Jesse, so he takes the boy on a road trip where the two get to know each other and embark on some adventures.
You don’t suppose Johnny will learn some lessons and grow up along the way, do you? Spoiler alert: yeah, though don’t expect C’mon to follow a typical feel-good path.
That doesn’t mean the story goes down dark avenues, as it maintains a fairly neutral attitude. Still, one shouldn’t expect real surprises from the ways in which Johnny reconnects with family and grows up a bit.
Honestly, the movie’s backstory related to the death of Johnny and Viv’s mother as well as Paul’s mental collapse all feels like windowdressing. Essentially the simple story of a middle-aged man who finally starts to grow up, it comes across like the filmmakers figured it needed more gravity, so they tacked on these deeper topics.
I disagree, and I think these more dramatic domains just distract from the main theme. The movie doesn’t need any “serious” rationale for the Johnny/Viv estrangement or the road trip, so these elements can seem unneeded.
That said, since so much of C’mon comes across as contrived, one might not even notice the unnecessary nature of those plot points. A collection of loosely connected scenes that involve self-absorbed characters, this becomes a tough tale to swallow.
Again, the various contrivances become a crutch. Johnny’s job allows him to act as the movie’s narrator, and a better-constructed film would function without this incessant “Johnny the Explainer” chatter.
Of course, Johnny’s career choice also allows him to visit various spots and engage Jesse in a variety of ways. Granted, most road trip films require some plot loop to exist, but this one feels even more forced than usual, especially because Johnny’s interviews come across as irrelevant editorializing.
These chats with random kids come across as an easy way to provide “social commentary” and they feel superfluous. The movie could – and would – fare better without the distractions they provide.
The lack of real characters or a substantial plot remains a serious issue here, as too much of C’mon feels like pretentious claptrap. We get pseudo-profundity from the interview subjects along with Johnny’s trite commentary and alleged “deep thoughts”.
Because the adults veer toward self-absorbed and self-pitying, they become a problematic base for the story, and Jesse doesn’t compensate. He alternates between obnoxious and precocious, without much personality in between these poles.
We’re supposed to like the kid but he just annoys, and not in a smart way. Jesse needs some charm to make Johnny warm to adulthood and parental responsibilities, but the kid feels like a movie creation and not a believable personality.
Really, that goes for C’mon as a whole. The film never offers more than self-serious pretentious episodes without much to satisfy.